Activist scorecards and demands have weighed on nearly every American institution, from government to academia to business. Of the three, corporate America has found success in shaking them off. It also has the clearest path to keep going. Government and academia are tied to elections and federal dollars. Business answers to customers and shareholders, and it can stay focused on them no matter who controls Congress.
Post-midterms, companies will face both political and activist pressure to walk back changes in governance that help them focus on business. These same companies must remember the activist playbook: The activists ask. The company yields to avoid retaliation. The activists ask again. The company complies to keep its standing. Then the activists demand, and the company finds itself under a yoke it never chose but consented to one step at a time.
The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) perfected this model with its Corporate Equality Index (CEI). The early requirements for a score of 100 were relatively minimal. Companies eager to display virtue signed on. Then, the HRC raised the bar year after year. Today, a CEI 100 requires companies to fully embrace gender ideology, follow guidance from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), and cover sex-denying interventions in employee health plans, including for minor dependents.
DEI and ESG activists ran the same play. Each group asked a little more, then a little more, in exchange for continued favor.
Over the last two years, a growing number of companies stopped playing. Yes, the Targets, Apples, and Amazons are still participating in the activist gambit, but others have rejected the distractions from core business strategy and carved new paths for others to follow.
- Walmart and Charles Schwab, for example, publicly proclaimed their lack of coverage for sex-denying procedures for minor dependents.
- Halliburton, ExxonMobil, and Chevron committed to meet energy demands by disregarding arbitrary climate activism.
- Mastercard, NVIDIA, DoorDash, and 6 others publicly removed the SPLC’s “hate list” as a filter on their charitable match programs.
- And there was a 65% drop in participation from the Fortune 500 in filling out the HRC’s CEI survey.
These companies are not perfect, but they are making progress back to business. They exemplify that there is good in weighing the cost of activism and choosing to move in a direction away from it. And what has the backlash been? These companies have been berated and accused by activists but have faced little impact on business. The cost of choosing business has been small.
The cost of choosing activism, on the other hand, has been large. We have seen in the case of Nike, Disney, Netflix, Starbucks, Bud Light, Accenture, IBM, Deloitte, Lockheed, the list goes on, that veering from business to activism has major financial consequences. Between massive stock collapse, million-dollar settlements over discriminatory hiring and firing, and customer loss over controversial ideological messaging, companies taking controversial stances are suffering compared to those who steer away from these harmful practices.
C-suites and boardrooms across the nation have continued to experience whiplash from the changing tides of politics, but they don’t have to. Instead of catering to the next activist movement by adding distractions that contribute to the whiplash, companies have the right to keep their eyes solely focused on business.
Congress will keep changing hands. Activist groups will keep raising the bar. Neither has to set a company’s agenda. Corporate America has already stepped back from activist demands at little cost. The companies that stay on that path will spend the next election cycle doing what they were built to do: serving customers and delivering returns.